Loading
Caterer & Hotelkeeper Magazine

Tags:

Review of the reviews

Joanna Wood
Wednesday 26 November 2003 16:03

15 November

Gillian Glover finds the food at the Skerries, Dunstane House hotel, Edinburgh, is not for the calorie-shy

The chef's favourite ingredient appears to be cream. He had added ample amounts of it to the seafood chowder with which I started. No potatoes or sweetcorn or anything remotely cheap sullied its silkiness. Just sweet plump mussels, some scallops and prawns, chunky flakes of fish and a fabulously shocking amount of cream. Rosemary Conley would have had a coronary just looking at it. (Two-course Sunday lunch for two, £40 - wine not included).

16 November

Jay Rayner erases his fears of eating bad food alone in Birmingham at Jessica's in Edgbaston

The best thing about this comely dining room lies beyond the kitchen doors, and his name is Glynn Purnell. His cooking is modern but not overwrought, subtle without being flyaway, satisfying without being overly rich. A starter of red mullet, the fillet cooked until the proteins have just set and partnered with a light sauce of Jerusalem artichokes beaten to a foam, shows the way. Bravely the mullet was allowed a distinct fishiness, which the artichoke undercut.

(Meal for two, including wine and service, £75-£100)

15 November

Matthew Fort discovers a crŠme caramel almost as good as his mother's at the Anchor & Hope, London SE1

The trembling, melting crŠme caramel was as fine an example of that pudding as I have eaten in an age, pressing closely on the steady perfection of my mother's version - the standard by which all crŠme caramels must be judged. Before that had come a roasted teal, off the daily specials board. The meat was tender, with that ringing sensuality that you get from wild duck. The sanguinary flow was mercifully sparse and quickly lost in the frisky red cabbage that came with it. (Three-course meal for two, including drinks, £83.30)

16 November

AA Gill tips the nod at Shumi, London, SW1

You're supposed to choose communally and share. But, whatever you choose to share, what you get is an old English curate's egg. The starters - monkfish and tuna carpaccio with aubergine confit, veal tartare with capers, roman artichoke and salted lemon salad - are, for the most part very good, occasionally nudging great. Fried quail's eggs with alba truffle were an absurd pleasure. Where the egg turns is with the main courses, which seem to come from a completely different kitchen.

(Rating: three stars out of five).

15 November

Jan Moir goes Viennese (three times) at Jeremy King and Christopher Corbin's new grand caf‚, the WolSEley, London W1

The main restaurant itself is separated into very distinct areas - a kind of Celebrity Central Zone in the middle, a row of covetable tables by the right-hand windows and one truly terrible table, right in front of the waiters' station, by the bar. Naturally, I was put there on the first of my three visits. The food is straightforward and good, but it does not dazzle. Pastries are very good and please make sure you don't skip the coffee, which is excellent.

(Lunch/dinner for two, excluding drinks, service and cover charges, £64).

Recommended articles

Articles from the web

 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Profiting from 2012: Case Studies

Slash VAT, Boost business - Sign the petition now!

Latest Video

housekeeping

Video: highlighting housekeepers

In this week’s issue, guest edited by Raymond Blanc, we explore the important roles of housekeepers.

Watch here

The Caterer and Hotelkeeper discussion forum

  • Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria
  • Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria
  • Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria: Mark Hayward Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria: Mark Hayward
  • Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria
  • Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria
  • Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria Dingley Dell Flying Visits @ The Victoria

Best of chef

Best of Chef – now available online

Best of Chef – now available online
View it now

Videos

Marcello Tully, Kinloch Lodge Video: Michelin-starred chefs turn out in force for Wellocks' chef conference Video: Highlights from Hotelympia 2012 Video: Foraging – why all the attention?
Marcello Tully
Masterclass
Watch the video here
Wellocks'
chef conference
Watch the video here
Highlights from
Hotelympia 2012
Watch the video here
Foraging:
why all the attention?
Watch the video here